Bonne Femme
Chapter 20
A Personal Message
Cartier, September
15, 4:15 PM
A pillowcase reduced Emily Palmer's existence to blurred gray. She couldn't even lift her hands from the armrests.
She listened as the footfalls diminished and ceased. After several minutes of dead silence she thought he had gone out
through the back. A loud ‘tick' made her jerk. A sulfurous odor assaulted her nostrils. Then he blew
cigarette smoke in her face. The sigh she heard made her recoil in horror. His face was nearly touching hers.
She struggled violently, but couldn't so much as rock the chair. Her attempt to scream was only a weak muffled protest
through the gag.
Mic knelt motionlessly and silent, savoring her helplessness as she bucked and strained against her bonds. He closed
his eyes for a moment to listen: the creaking of the chair, the rapid breathing, and the choked sobs. All of it
was good, but he wanted to see her eyes.
Not this time.
342.
A movement at the window!
A black cat was on the brick sill outside. It slid back and forth, brushing first one and then the other side against
the glass. Like a familiar spirit, the preening beast evoked a childhood memory.
The mewling had drawn
him to the big maple behind the house. A huge black cat crouched and growled menacingly. Between its
paws was a fledgling robin.
Mic took the cord from his pocket and moved behind the chair. He lowered a loop carefully. When it touched the
bare skin below her collarbone she flinched. Slowly he eased it up under the pillowcase, setting off a renewed spate
of futile struggling.
The cat sank its claws possessively as Mic neared. With baleful eyes it bit almost tenderly into the captive.
The hapless bird fluttered in pain and terror. The cat lingered, delaying the inevitable while its yellow eyes blazed
with wild passion.
Mic
tightened the garrote experimentally, eliciting a satisfying fit of thrashing panic.
Fascinated, he poked
at the cat with a stick. It bit down, and the fluttering increased as the doomed victim tried vainly to break free.
With
closed his eyes he savored the feel of her life in his fingers. He maintained a steady light tension, just enough to
block the blood flow and build up pressure in the blood vessels of the face without cutting off oxygen to her brain.
He eased off before she lost consciousness.
After she gasped in two deep breaths, he tightened the noose again, applying more force. Her panic brought the familiar
build up, like a roller coaster pushing higher and higher as it approached the peak before hurtling downward. The sudden
descent into mayhem beckoned, but he resisted. The girl coughed as he eased up and released the breath that he had been
holding.
He looked down at his "little bird." Suddenly, he jerked the garrote up viciously, pulling the chair from
the floor. Holding her suspended, he calmly checked his watch.
Twelve minutes to go.
He lowered her to the floor and released
the cord. He took deep drags on the cigarette as she coughed around the gag. When her breathing had approached
a normal pace, he knelt in front of her. She craned straining to determine where he was. It amused him.
He took a last deep drag, removed the cigarette from his lips, and studied the malevolently glowing coal at the end.
After he was through with
her, he emptied her purse onto the couch and took the money from the wallet. A quick look at his watch told him that
it was time to go. At the last second he decided to take the cell phone. On his way out back, he took one last
look at her. Through the front window he saw a car pull up. He was still in the back yard when he heard it.
"Emmy!"
343.
4:50
PM
That the crime had taken place in an unincorporated subdivision meant that the Sheriff's department had sole jurisdiction.
JR stopped on a sheet of plastic just inside the door and looked in. The living room was as immaculate as a layout for
Better Homes and Gardens except for an armchair festooned with duck tape sitting in the middle of the floor. The head
of the processing team looked up briefly to acknowledge him before feeding a pillowcase into an evidence bag.
"Finding anything useful?" he asked.
"Except
for the tape, nothing else appears imported. The ligature was cut from the blinds over there, the pillowcase he slipped
over her head came from the bedroom. We'll dust and look for trace, but the scene looks pretty sterile. Our best
bet is to get a print from the tape."
"Know how he got in?"
"Not sure. She says he was waiting for her
when she got home. No jimmy marks, so she forgot to lock up, he had a key, or he picked the lock. If the old man
hadn't come home she'd be dead. You should see the marks on her neck."
"How much of the scene is clear?" asked JR.
"Not
much. This room's been photographed, but nothings been vacuumed and we're not through dusting for latents. So
stay where you are or put on booties."
JR noted the dumped purse.
"That
been cataloged?"
"Yeah, but no one's checked with her to see if anything's missing. The wallet's empty though."
"Give me your list. I'm going out to
talk to her."
"We may have something in the kitchen," he said as he handed it over. "A cigarette butt and scuff-mark
where the perp ground it out. It would be great to get DNA from the cigarette. A scraping of the scuffmark for
chem analysis might be useful if we find shoes with a consistent chemical composition. It's not much, but it could help
in court if we catch him."
"I'll get right on that," said JR over his shoulder as he went back outside to get the victim's story.
The
tall, thirty-year-old deputy stepped from the van and slid the door closed as he arrived.
344.
"She gonna be okay, Gwen?"
The department's rape counselor shrugged.
"Depends on what you mean by ‘okay.'"
"Can I see her yet?"
"I
wish you'd hold off a bit. Besides, I don't know what she could tell you. She didn't see anything. He slipped
something over her head as soon as she stepped through the door. Besides saying he was strong, she couldn't tell me
anything---not if he was big, small, white, black. Maybe she'll remember something later."
"She can't tell us anything about him?"
"According
to her, he didn't say a word. I know. He had to say something---make a threat or something. She says he
was quiet---didn't even make enough noise for her to guess his age."
"Lead me through the sequence of the attack."
"He
pulled something over her head as soon as she came in, took her straight to the chair, tied her to it with tape. By
the way, he had already placed the chair in the middle of the room. After he immobilized her he played at killing with
her---those are my words, not hers. What he did was put a noose around her neck and tightened it enough to make her
think he was killing her. The bruising confirms that. I'm taking her to the clinic in a minute."
"The
sadistic bastard even held a cigarette to her. One of her fingernails is as red as a beet. Poor little girl.
If her daddy hadn't come home in time she'd be dead."
"After you get her settled, I need your report.
Sooner rather than later I'm gonna have to talk to her."
He pulled the notepad sheet from his breast pocket.
"Before you go have her look at this to see if he took anything
from her purse."
She took it and went inside the van where Emily Palmer sat huddled against her father. After a few minutes she emerged
and handed it back.
"Her
cell phone's missing. She thinks that's all."
345.
"Tell them not to cancel
service on it."
"For what it's worth, we've got the crime scene for as long as we want. Her dad's taking her to his sister's place.
Says he'd burn this place to the ground if he could. He also says he's going to find the guy."
"I can understand that."
5:20 PM
The
way she stood with arms crossed and shooting him that look made him want to take her by the throat.
"I got held up in traffic,"
he said, baring his teeth in a smile he couldn't summon the energy to make look sincere. "Did you get what I wanted?"
"You said to be here at four forty-five.
That was half an hour ago."
"Sorry,"
he said as he took a bite.
"It's
cold, isn't it?"
She stepped
closer, the fabric of her blouse touching his chest.
"Maybe you'd like something a little warmer."
Brushing up against me like a whore, he thought. Trying to play me.
He ran his hands up her back.
I pity the poor slob who marries her. She'll blow up like a pig as soon as she gets a meal ticket.
"I know what
you want," she whispered.
He smiled and crushed her to him.
"That's more like my man," she breathed huskily.
"I got something for you."
"What is it?"
"Come on. You'll see when
we get there. We'll take your car and I'll fill it up with gas for you on the way back."
346.
Lake County Courthouse,
September 16, 2:00 PM
"This is a fishing expedition," said Judge Clarke as he laid aside the petition.
"Your
honor, the suspect had a relationship with strangling victim, Rose Ford," replied the prosecutor. "And two
other women whom he knew were strangled likewise. The method was the same as that which would have resulted in the death
of Emily Palmer had her father not interrupted the perpetrator."
"You know I can't take all that into consideration
in evaluating this. I'm going to have to narrowly define the warrant. You can look for the Miss Palmer's cell
phone."
"But, your honor, we need to be able to seize the rest of it. If we don't there's a good chance that the search
will just tip him off and give him an opportunity to destroy vital evidence for other cases against him."
"Then
maybe a search warrant is premature, especially for this . . ." The judge paused to read the list aloud.
"Bondage and sadomasochistic paraphernalia, violent pornographic materials, diaries, paper and computer files, computer
storage devices, photographs, video tapes, women's clothing, jewelry items . . . Tell me how any of that pertains
to the Palmer case?"
5:30 PM
Mic smirked as read the warrant.
"Phone
cops, huh?" He looked past JR toward the street. "When will the mattress tag officers get here?"
"I
have a few questions for you before we conduct the search, if you don't mind," said JR.
"I got a choice?"
"Not really. Let's sit down."
JR placed a small tape recorder on the kitchen table and started it
rolling.
"You are suspected in the assault of Emily Palmer yesterday afternoon. Anything you tell me could be used as evidence
against you. Want a lawyer?"
347.
"I got nothing to hide. Emily who?"
"So
you understand that you have a right to a lawyer and that you don't have to say anything---"
"Yeah, yeah," said
Mic as he reached for a cigarette. "And you've got a right not breath my secondhand smoke, so you can leave anytime
you want."
Mic blew
smoke in JR's direction.
After stating
the date and place of the questioning, JR began.
"You are William McCulloch Boyd, correct?"
"Yeah."
"Where
were you yesterday afternoon?"
"Let's
see---out to the lake, I think."
"Can
anyone verify that?"
"I
doubt it."
"So you were
alone?"
"Perceptive.
Been detecting long?"
"So
from four to six yesterday afternoon no one can verify where you were?"
"No. I was alone.
I guess if I need an alibi for yesterday, I'm out of luck. I just kicked around out at the lake, picked up some food
on the way back here, and then spent the night alone."
"I'm going to ask you to sit on the sofa in there while we search the place."
"No can do. I got places to go and
things to do. You can't keep me here."
"I'm afraid I can. Now sit down in there until we're done."
"Well get on with it or it'll take all damned night."
348.
"You noticed the warrant mentioned your car
too," said JR.
Boyd appeared
irritated but unconcerned.
"Just
get on with it," he said.
JR
stopped the tape recorder.
"Hal,
John, go out and search his car. I'll do the house."
JR scanned the checklist and then walked through a cursory inspection,
noting that the apartment looked more like a motel room than a home. No pictures decorated the walls or dresser tops.
No magazines were scattered about. Nothing personal warmed the place. The living room contained only the couch on which
Mic sat smoking, and a dust covered TV hooked to cable, but with neither VCR nor DVD.
He had Boyd stand up and then checked
under the cushions before running his hands into the crevices beneath. Turning the sofa on its back, he checked to see
if the lining underneath had been pulled loose. Finding nothing, he checked the TV stand.
The kitchen wasn't spotless,
but nothing appeared out of place: no dirty dishes, no empty glasses or cups, and an empty trash bin.
In the bedroom he found butts
in an ashtray. Like the one Mic was smoking, they had beige filters instead of the white filter on the butt from the
Palmer house. The closet contained clothes hung with military precision: shirts to the left, pants to the right,
and all hung at equal intervals. A pair of leather soled black shoes sat on the closet floor. He had noticed earlier
that the athletic shoes Mic wore had an off-white, not black, tread. The dresser drawers contained neatly folded clothes,
segregated by type and color. Socks were bundled military style, and aligned as if in anticipation of an imminent inspection.
Back
in the kitchen, he found a half empty six-pack of San Miguel, an unopened quart of milk, and a white paper bag in the refrigerator.
Inside the bag was a partially eaten cheeseburger. The ticket stapled to it identified it as purchased at Burger Town
at 4:29 the previous day. It was suspiciously convenient, but an alibi nonetheless.
JR scanned the checklist
used as SOP when conducting a search. Xeroxed from an FBI handout obtained at a workshop two years earlier, it cataloged
both obvious and unusual hiding places room by room.
349.
He began with the kitchen, where
the cabinets held nothing of interest and there appeared to be no hidden doors or compartments. He checked behind and
under the refrigerator and stove, examined the light fixtures and outlet covers for signs of a hiding place, and turned over
the metal frame table to see if the feet attached to the hollow metal legs had recently been removed. After carefully
checking the baseboards for seams betraying a hidden panel to the interior of the wall, he examined the vinyl flooring and
ceiling tiles. Finding nothing, he went back to the bedroom.
In the bedroom closet he found a ceiling panel giving
entrance to the low attic. Standing on a chair, he used a flashlight to examine the dark space overhead. A thick
layer of undisturbed dust covering the foil-backed insulation told him that nothing had been hidden there, at least not for
several years. He climbed down and began examining the dressers, removing drawers and checking for things taped
to their bottoms or inside the frames.
Behind the bureau mirror he found something that quickened his pulse, a small faux-leather diary of the type sold in discount
stores. He read through its three filled pages quickly and then put it back where he had found it and went outside where
the deputies had finished with the car.
"Nothing in the car, JR," said Hal as he handed over the clipboard.
"Nothing in there either, boys," he replied.
Because
he was looking for it, he saw just a twitch of surprise in Mic's face, before it settled quickly into a blank expression.
"You
guys can go on home," he said. "I'll sign you out when I go back to write this up."
As the patrol car disappeared
around the corner, Mic lit a cigarette, flipped the spent match past JR, fixed him with a stare. Then he smiled.
"I haven't done a thing to you, so why are
you doing this?"
"I'm just
doing the job."
"No.
You're making this personal. That's a big mistake."
"I don't know what you're talking
about, but I am curious about your remark that you haven't done anything to me. Why would you say that?"
350.
"Maybe
because you've been out to get me ever since Rose Ford disappeared. Now you're trying to nail me for this other woman.
I don't even know her. What is it? Am I going to be your suspect every time someone attacks a woman in the county?"
"Like
I told you, I'm just doing the job. If you haven't done anything then you don't have anything to worry about."
"I
guess you're right," said Mic. "None of us have anything to worry about---me, Ricky, Jill, you . . . or Betty."
At the sound of his wife's name, JR's hand drifted unconsciously to the butt of his nightstick. Mic thought it hilarious.
"Simmer down, JR. It was a joke."
"Get
near my wife, and I promise I'll blow your damned head off!" he said, meaning every word of it.
Mic laughed.
"Well, I'm sure you feel all better now," he said.
September 17
A string
of motionless boxcars blocked the way three blocks from the Palmer house. It took an unusually long train to block Lowell
Street, but apparently that's what they had.
"I've got to be back in two hours," said Richard. "Jill's third class is out at the north campus.
I don't want her walking that far alone."
"I'll get you back in time," replied JR as a crescendo of clangs rang out as the switch engine tugged slack from
the couplings.
Graffiti
covered boxcars began creeping toward the switchyard.
"Hand me that thermos at your feet," he said.
He poured a cup for Richard and a capful for himself.
"I came across two interesting
items in Boyd's apartment. There was a sack from the drive-in over on Market with a ticket that shows it was bought
about the time the attack."
351.
"Someone else picked it up."
"Probably.
I also found a sort of . . . diary. It had a bunch of vague references to the three of you."
"The three of us?"
"He
makes it sound like there was some kind of weird . . . triangular affair going on."
"I told you that he
and Jill dated for several months last year before she and I got together. We all hung around at the college together,
but there weren't three of us. There were four. Marta was with us. Is that what he was writing about?"
"Not
exactly. He makes it sound like you and him had something . . . like a bisexual thing going when you were in the Marines
together."
"That's
laughable," said Richard.
"It would be except one of the entries implies that you let a . . . a sex thing get out of hand . . . like maybe you
accidentally killed a prostitute over in Africa."
"That's ridiculous! You can talk to anyone who knew
us in Somalia. I had nothing to do with him over there that wasn't duty related. I certainly never went whoring
with him, not that much of that was going on over there. We were all so afraid of contracting AIDS that Somalia was
probably the most celibate military operation in history."
"Maybe he was talking about female military personnel?
Don't tell me there was none of that kind fraternization going on?"
"There was, only not for me."
"Do you remember a woman getting killed?"
"One of us? No.
And I would have heard. Everyone would have heard. The media would have been on it like flies on roadkill."
The last of the boxcars cleared, and JR put the
car in gear.
"The diary also suggests that you may have killed Rose Ford, and that he was worried that you might kill Jill.
My opinion is that he's trying to muddy the waters---and he's doing a damned good job of it. Without physical evidence
connecting him to any of the crimes, discrediting you and confusing people as to the real relationship between you two is
a good tactic. No telling what a jury would make of it."
352.
"What do the rest of them think about it?"
"The
diary? I didn't take it in. Wasn't on the warrant. Neither was the bag in the refrigerator," he said
with a laugh as they pulled to the curb. "He brought it in this morning. I guess I'll have to testify that
I saw it in the refrigerator during the search if this goes to trial, but I didn't tell him that."
JR unlocked the door, and they ducked the crime
scene tape and went in.
"His alibi isn't as good as he thinks. In fact it cuts two ways. If you assume he cooked it up then it shows
premeditation. And whoever picked it up for him is open to charges of abetting which could be used to drive a wedge
between them. Anyway, that's the prosecutor's business," mumbled JR as they walked to an armchair positioned at
a forty-five degree angle near the center of the cold room.
"You see why he put her here?" he asked absently.
He stood behind the chair.
"The chair faces the
door. It's the first thing you'd see when you came in. Using a chair fits, doesn't it? He taped victims
to one in West Virginia and in Walker."
"No, JR. The men weren't his victims. They were his audience. This is different."
"Maybe
it was just a variation on his theme---strangling from behind just like the others."
"It's not right,"
Richard insisted. "She was fully clothed, and the others were strangled in the bedroom."
"Who knows what he did
to the others before he killed them? Maybe he stripped them after they were dead."
"I don't understand
the pillowcase either, JR---unless it's like standing behind them so he won't see their faces. Maybe he visualizes another
face, pretends that they're someone else."
"Leave that for the shrink to ask while he's waiting for lethal injection," said JR. "Oh. He added
one other thing this time. Her dad interrupted him as he was torturing her. Besides repeatedly strangling her
to the point of unconsciousness, he held a cigarette---"
"To one of her fingernails," Richard interrupted.
353.
"How did you know that? It wasn't released
to the media. "
"He did it during an interrogation in Mogadishu," said Richard, as a possible explanation began to form.
"This is crazy, JR. But I think he
did that to tip me that it was him."
"Why
would he deliberately point a finger at himself."
"He told me once that it didn't matter what people
knew if they couldn't prove it. Now I understand the pillowcase. It wasn't that he didn't want to see her face.
He didn't want her to see his because he planned to let her live."
"These guys don't de-escalate,"
objected JR. "Besides, you should see the marks on her neck. He got real close to killing her."
"But
he didn't. Try this out: he knows her schedule, so he breaks in waits for her to come home. He gains control
of her without letting her see his face. Then he ties her here in the chair where he can watch the street. Then
he spends . . . what? Maybe half an hour tormenting her, acting out strangling her? But he doesn't kill her because
that's not part of the plan this time. He knows her father's schedule too, so he stretches it out to make it look like
he was interrupted before he was through."
"I think you're giving him too much credit. The simple explanation is that the old man came home before he expected,
or maybe he didn't know that she lived with her father."
"No I'm not. This was like a raid. He
scouted it first and then picked his time, and set a timetable. I think this went down just like he planned."
"I still don't buy it. These guys are
about one thing, and one thing only."
"A forensic psychologist told me that it was foolish to think
they were all alike. If it was only blood lust that motivated him, he would have stuck to the script. You'd have
found both of them in the bedroom, the old man in this chair, and the daughter on the bed."
"Then why did he do this?"
Chill certainty gripped him.
"To
send a message. He's saying, ‘It's me, and you can't stop me.' But he's wrong. The circle of people
who suspect him is getting wider and wider."
"That circle is what bothers me, Richard."
354.
"Why?"
"Because you're at the center of it. It was created
by you."
"You suspect me?"
"Of
course not, but a defense lawyer would have a hay day with all this. Everything connecting him to a victim is related
to something you've said or done. You went to Missouri to dig into the death of that girl and you convinced the West
Virginia people to consider him for the Scott homicides. The topper is that you came to me about Rose Ford, and this
story about the cigarette torture. I'm a friend of your, Richard. Any decent lawyer would have that out of me
before my butt warms the witness chair."
"It could be painted as you conducting a jealousy inspired vendetta with me misusing my authority to help you do in your
rival."
"A
jury would never believe that."
"Well, they wouldn't have to, would they? All they'd
have to do would be to develop a reasonable doubt. Speaking of which, there's a ready made alternate suspect for them
to use in the Palmer case---namely you."
"How am I a suspect?"
"Got an alibi?"
"I
was at home with Jill."
"So it's back to the triangle he wrote about in his diary: two violent guys obsessed with the same girl.
Actually, it's not all that unbelievable if you think about it. The accusations you guys are making against each other
go back to some really nasty stuff in Somalia. How's a jury supposed to wade its way through all that to return a guilty
verdict?"
"Just
tell me that you still believe me, JR."
"Yeah. He even helped in that regard.
After the search, he mentioned Betty. I almost lost it."
"Did he make a threat?"
"No, but I showed her
a picture so she would know what he looks like, and I got my brother's German Shepherd staying in the house with us.
She's a great burglar alarm."
355.
A Premonition
2:30 AM,
September 18
"What---" he gasped, jolting upright.
Jill sat on the edge of the couch, silhouetted against the window.
"What's wrong?" he asked, trying to still the rapid beating
of his heart.
"I cannot sleep."
In
the dark, her voice sounded like that of a frightened child---not at all like her.
"I should have never
told you about all that stuff JR said. You've got enough to worry about with that hypothetical stuff about the trial.
You want to stay out here tonight?"
"I kept hearing things. I thought someone---he was in the house with us. I know it is foolish."
"Not at all. It's like when we were---"
"Please,"
she said, interrupting him. "I am not in the mood for another of your military analogies. Just come into
the bedroom so that I will know where you are and that nothing is happening to you. Maybe I can sleep then."
"Are you mad at me?"
"I am not angry with you, Richard. I am angry with the situation."
"The situation I have caused."
"We
both helped cause it," she said, standing up. "Perhaps if you or I had done things differently he
would not be doing this. Or perhaps he would be doing it to someone else. Bring your pillow."
As
he arranged his pillow and bedclothes on one side of the bed, she locked the bedroom door and propped a chair beneath the
knob. She took the .45 from the nightstand.
"Keep this tonight," she said.
356.
He removed the clip.
"With
that hair trigger, I don't think having a round ready to fire is a good idea," he said.
After removing the round
in the chamber, he reinserted the clip and placed the automatic under his pillow.
"Besides, if he does try to get
in, the sound of a round being chambered might give him second thoughts."
Settled down and bundled in his blanket
like a caterpillar in a cocoon, he had almost drifted into sleep when she spoke.
"I was angry with you," she
said. "I kept thinking about the Palmer girl and that he wishes to do the same to me. Then I thought that
he would never have even met me if not for you. I know that you are protecting me, but I should not need protecting.
Why does this have to happen?"
He wished he could think of new words to reassure her, but nothing came to him.
"Jill, I'm---"
"Do not apologize again.
It changes nothing. Besides, you are no more to blame than I. Aunt Mirabelle says that one cannot help what happens,
but one can help where one is. I went to the wrong place, Richard."
"To Cartier?"
"No. To Mic. I knew better."
"That was my fault," he said.
"You had no influence on me."
She turned her back to him,
adjusting the covers as if to signal an end to the conversation. After a few minutes of silence, he thought she had
fallen asleep.
"We must find a way to end this," she said suddenly. "I cannot do this much longer."
"I
think we're well on the way to doing just that. Everyone's convinced that he's responsible for both the Walker thing
and Rose Ford."
357.
"Then why does someone not arrest him?" she
asked bitterly.
"Acting prematurely could ruin any chance at prosecution. When you arrest someone, then you have to charge them.
Without enough evidence to convict, you're just wasting you time putting them on trial."
"I know how the legal
system works," she said. "But you said he would stop. You said he would go away if they got interested
in him. It is not happening, Richard. Now I cannot even run away and be safe. He will follow me."
He
wanted to hold her. But was that for her sake or his own? Suddenly he was more afraid than he had ever been, not
of Mic, but of his own weakness. He had been fooling himself---and her. He was unequal to the task, and had been
from the beginning.
"No, he won't," he said. "I want you to go home. Tomorrow I'll get the money for you. You
find a good school there. I promise that I'll send you the money you need to finish your education. You can count
on it."
A long silence
followed.
"I cannot go back,"
she finally said.
"Sure you
can. I want you to."
"But I do not want to," she said, turning back
toward him. "So we continue doing what we are doing until it ends. What else is there?"
In the night he woke to find her curled
against him. He thought about putting his arm around her, but didn't.
Jill awoke later and thought about moving back to her side of the bed,
but she didn't.
Of course neither
of them spoke about it in the morning.